Alerting the user for disk errors
Posted: Sun Jan 02, 2011 10:46 am
Hello,
I just build a new HDA and wanted to move all my data from the old one. Because having two HDA's 'online' did not seem like a good idea, I installed Fedora 14 on the old one, so I could access my data drives. As soon as the install finished and I logged in on the desktop I was greeted with a HUGE warning pop-up telling me that one of my disks had lots of bad sectors and was probably failing. And sure enough, when trying to copy data this became a very real problem. (it was one of 2 drives from the greyhole pool and not for all my files I had activated extra copies)
I have been using the Amahi server without ever noticing anything. I don't know how I should have. It doesn't seem that Amahi is configured for sending mails if it detects problems. There is also nothing on the dashboard for alerting users to problems. On a server that's mainly used for storing files something like that should really be integrated, especially if Fedora already implemented it! On my old WHS I got mails for things like fan speed too low, disk storage lower than a certain threshold, cpu temps, etc.
I would suggest putting something like this high on some 'to-do' list (if it isn't already). Having a lot of apps is all very nice, but if the foundation is breaking down beneath them without anyone noticing ....
Sorry, I'm a bit .... If I missed anything or set up my server wrong PLEASE tell me!
Richard
I just build a new HDA and wanted to move all my data from the old one. Because having two HDA's 'online' did not seem like a good idea, I installed Fedora 14 on the old one, so I could access my data drives. As soon as the install finished and I logged in on the desktop I was greeted with a HUGE warning pop-up telling me that one of my disks had lots of bad sectors and was probably failing. And sure enough, when trying to copy data this became a very real problem. (it was one of 2 drives from the greyhole pool and not for all my files I had activated extra copies)
I have been using the Amahi server without ever noticing anything. I don't know how I should have. It doesn't seem that Amahi is configured for sending mails if it detects problems. There is also nothing on the dashboard for alerting users to problems. On a server that's mainly used for storing files something like that should really be integrated, especially if Fedora already implemented it! On my old WHS I got mails for things like fan speed too low, disk storage lower than a certain threshold, cpu temps, etc.
I would suggest putting something like this high on some 'to-do' list (if it isn't already). Having a lot of apps is all very nice, but if the foundation is breaking down beneath them without anyone noticing ....
Sorry, I'm a bit .... If I missed anything or set up my server wrong PLEASE tell me!
Richard